Main Text
TM001 — mm
Feb 16, 2009 · tekhelet · Archive message lookup
Micha, we’ve discussed this several times, and this is not “conclusive”, is it?** There is nothing new discovered recently, is there? He says it’s the Murex truncullus.
A friend emails me and some others:
“I think I had seen a TV program on this, but a recent article in last weeks’ Jewish Press newspaper rekindled interest in this.
This group of rabbinic scientists in Israel have conclusively discovered the source of the blue dye used in the bible for dying corners of the tallis.
See: www.tekhelet.com
They are now producing and selling the stuff.
The article is on pages 21-22 of the 6Feb09 Jewish Press newspaper.”
**Unless there is another meaning of conclusive that just means someone has reached a conclusion. Well the third entry at dictionary.com seems to have such a meaning. I don’t think anyone is doing it here, but using “conclusive” this way would be an easy way to lie.
TM002 — Adelle
Feb 16, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
“mm” <NOPSAMmm2005@bigfoot.com> wrote in message news:hqdhp41vdq33gg1ofo1gonqidv39jgubit@4ax.com…
Micha, we’ve discussed this several times, and this is not “conclusive”, is it?** There is nothing new discovered recently, is there? He says it’s the Murex truncullus.
A friend emails me and some others:
“I think I had seen a TV program on this, but a recent article in last weeks’ Jewish Press newspaper rekindled interest in this.
This group of rabbinic scientists in Israel have conclusively discovered the source of the blue dye used in the bible for dying corners of the tallis.
See: www.tekhelet.com
They are now producing and selling the stuff.
The article is on pages 21-22 of the 6Feb09 Jewish Press newspaper.”
**Unless there is another meaning of conclusive that just means someone has reached a conclusion. Well the third entry at dictionary.com seems to have such a meaning. I don’t think anyone is doing it here, but using “conclusive” this way would be an easy way to lie.
Our Rabbi did a torah study on techelet within the last year – on whether techelet was required for tzitziyot. He did have at least one handout discussing whether the source of the dye had been found with any certainty. I’ll see if he still has access to the sources he quoted and I’ll pass them on to you. He is away for most of this week, so If I don’t post by week’s end, please remind me.
Adelle
TM003 — Micha Berger
Feb 16, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
mm <NOPSAMmm2005@bigfoot.com> wrote:
Micha, we’ve discussed this several times, and this is not “conclusive”, is it?** There is nothing new discovered recently, is there? He says it’s the Murex truncullus.
I do not think it’s conclusive.
However, Josephus, who did wear techeiles in the Second Temple, identified the source of the techeiles to be the same as royal purple — which would make it the murex snail. The Arukh believed the accuracy of Josephus’s desscription. Of their arguments, that one seems the most compelling. Unfortunately, the Amutah IMHO oversells their point, which in effect creates strawmen that the opposition can easily knock down.
I wear it for a different reason…
There is a dispute as to whether the white strings of the tzitzis are better off being white, or matching the color of the garment. They are the “sprouts of the corner” (tzitzis haqanaf), which would indicate that despite the gemara calling them lavan (white) the verse implies they should match the garment.
Yemenite Jews follow Maimonides, and match the garment.
Ashkenazi and Sepharedi custom is to avoid the question by wearing a white garment. In fact, Seph go further and don’t even wear colored striped on their tallisos — their stripes are white-on-white.
(BTW, the reason for the stripes is probably just that the original style when the talllis was in style, during the Greek empire, was to have stripes. The word itself is a Greek loan word, the “-is” is a sigma, not a sav (thus proving the Ashk sav isn’t all that new.) Ashk wear blue stripes in memory of techeiles, or black stripes in mourning for it.
Post facto (bedi’eved), the tzitzis are kosher either way.
But that’s for the white strings. But we wear 8 strings even without techeiles. Really: 4 strings with 8 ends hanging out the tassle. 4 of those ends (according to Rashi and Tosafos) or 2 (Raaavad) or 1 (Rambam) are supposed to be blue, and just worn today to round out the full 8.
Even bedi’eved, the replacement has no preferred color.
So, one can fully fulfill the mitzvah of white strings while still *perhaps* fulfilling that of techeiles by wearing the replacement strings dyed in that maybe-techeiles.
After reading Rav Hirsch’s description of the meaning of the eigth string being blue — that eight is beyond the natural (created in a week) , and the blue is the same metaphore as sapphire floor seen by the elders at Mt Sinai (at the end of this week’s parashah — I felt a strong emotional attachment to at least trying to fulfill the Rambam’s opinion.
Following the Rambam also means that one is not sacrificing any chance of fulfilling the same mitzvah as anyone else. One has a chance of fulfilling the full biblical mitzvah of tzitzis and the only cost is financial.
Tir’u baTov! -Micha
TM004 — Ron Aaron
Feb 16, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
On Feb 16, 3:48 am, mi…@aishdas.org (Micha Berger) wrote:
Following the Rambam also means that one is not sacrificing any chance of fulfilling the same mitzvah as anyone else. One has a chance of fulfilling the full biblical mitzvah of tzitzis and the only cost is financial.
Which of the Rambam’s halachoth are you fulfilling? The one which states that non-kosher techeleth *invalidates* the SiSith? The one which states you must purchase the techeleth from a *mumHeh* (expert) ?
Are you not transgressing thereby the prohibition of wearing a four-cornered garment without proper SiSith, given there are at least five different “correct” versions of techeleth being marketed, none of which are the same, and obviously not all of which can be correct!
TM005 — Micha Berger
Feb 16, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
Ron Aaron <rambamist@gmail.com> wrote:
Following the Rambam also means that one is not sacrificing any chance of fulfilling the same mitzvah as anyone else. One has a chance of fulfilling the full biblical mitzvah of tzitzis and the only cost is financial.
Which of the Rambam’s halachoth are you fulfilling? The one which states that non-kosher techeleth *invalidates* the SiSith? The one which states you must purchase the techeleth from a *mumHeh* (expert) ?
As I wrote earlier in that post:
But that’s for the white strings. But we wear 8 strings even without techeiles. Really: 4 strings with 8 ends hanging out the tassle. 4 of those ends (according to Rashi and Tosafos) or 2 (Raaavad) or 1 (Rambam) are supposed to be blue, and just worn today to round out the full 8.
Even bedi’eved, the replacement has no preferred color.
Tir’u baTov! -Micha
TM006 — Giorgies E Kepipesiom
Feb 16, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
On Feb 16, 7:56 am, mi…@aishdas.org (Micha Berger) wrote:
Ron Aaron <rambam…@gmail.com> wrote:
Following the Rambam also means that one is not sacrificing any chance of fulfilling the same mitzvah as anyone else. One has a chance of fulfilling the full biblical mitzvah of tzitzis and the only cost is financial.
Which of the Rambam’s halachoth are you fulfilling? The one which states that non-kosher techeleth *invalidates* the SiSith? The one which states you must purchase the techeleth from a *mumHeh* (expert) ?
As I wrote earlier in that post:
But that’s for the white strings. But we wear 8 strings even without techeiles. Really: 4 strings with 8 ends hanging out the tassle. 4 of those ends (according to Rashi and Tosafos) or 2 (Raaavad) or 1 (Rambam) are supposed to be blue, and just worn today to round out the full 8.
Even bedi’eved, the replacement has no preferred color.
I am going to violate my own earlier statement that I would not be joining the discussion. And if memory serves, this will be the first time I come to the defense of Micha Berger, whom I am usually on the opposing side of. Since the Maimonidean view is that only one half-strand of the eight is dyed tekhelet (i.e., one of the four strands is half white and half tekhelet), using non-kosher tekhelet would not invalidate the seesith, bexause the seesith would be kosher even were that strand entirely missing. See Qisur Shulhan Arukh Chap 9, par 13, about 1/3 way into the paragraph; also Hayyei Adam chapt 11, par 20. Nonetheless, because of the safeq, one could not mix wool and linen is this tallith, and so, even were the murex dye genuine tekhelet, the miswa would not be fullfilled in the best possible manner, which would require white strands of linen and blue strand of wool. But would still be prefferable to no blue at all. Having said all this, I still wear white only, until such time as yavo more sedeq veyodieinu.
If you are going to use the funny spellings, I would point out the Hebrew name for these strings has a hiriq malei for the first sadi and a hiriq haser for the second. Thus the funny spelling ought be seesith, not sisith. Regarding the funny capitalistion I will not comment save to point out that there is no need to capitalise this word at all.
Gershon Eliyahu no longer a disciple of Master Israel Tekhelet
TM007 — mirjam
Feb 16, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
Some Colleagues of mine [ fiberartists] tried to make the color themselves ,
mirjam
ps i think they wrote about it i will look if i still have the article ,
TM008 — Ron Aaron
Feb 16, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
On Feb 16, 2:56 pm, mi…@aishdas.org (Micha Berger) wrote:
As I wrote earlier in that post:
But that’s for the white strings. But we wear 8 strings even without techeiles. Really: 4 strings with 8 ends hanging out the tassle. 4 of those ends (according to Rashi and Tosafos) or 2 (Raaavad) or 1 (Rambam) are supposed to be blue, and just worn today to round out the full 8.
Even bedi’eved, the replacement has no preferred color.
It is an interesting assertion that the eight is a “replacement”. Either you have seven “lavan” and one “techelet”, or eight “lavan”. What is your support for saying the Rambam says otherwise? I do not see that in the M”T anywhere.
TM009 — Micha Berger
Feb 16, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
Ron Aaron <rambamist@gmail.com> wrote:
It is an interesting assertion that the eight is a “replacement”. Either you have seven “lavan” and one “techelet”, or eight “lavan”. What is your support for saying the Rambam says otherwise? I do not see that in the M”T anywhere.
Where does the Rambam address having 8 lavan altogether?
And why am I constrained to the Rambam?
Tir’u baTov! -Micha
TM010 — Ron Aaron
Feb 16, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
Where does the Rambam address having 8 lavan altogether?
8 strands, altogether. One techelet and 7 white, or 8 white. hilchot SiSith 1:9.
And why am I constrained to the Rambam?
I never claimed you were; you are the one making claims based upon the Rambam:
Following the Rambam also means that one is not sacrificing any chance of fulfilling the same mitzvah as anyone else. One has a chance of fulfilling the full biblical mitzvah of tzitzis and the only cost is financial.
TM011 — Micha Berger
Feb 16, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
Ron Aaron <rambamist@gmail.com> wrote:
Where does the Rambam address having 8 lavan altogether?
8 strands, altogether. One techelet and 7 white, or 8 white. hilchot SiSith 1:9.
No, he gives instruction how to tie if one doesn’t have a blue string to wrap around the others.
Of course the Rambaam assumes you have 4 string with 8 ends. How can you have a one-ended string? But the Rambam doesn’t say “make all 8 white”. In fact, he says, “If you are making white strings without the techeiles, take on of the 8 strings…” Where is the imperative about the 8th string being white? Third, “lavan” here is a technical term used by the gemara, and according to Hilkhos Tzitzis 1:1 wouldn’t mean white unless the garment is white. (“The tassle which is made on the corner of the garment is of the same kind as the garment.”)
And why am I constrained to the Rambam?
I never claimed you were; you are the one making claims based upon the Rambam:
Following the Rambam also means that one is not sacrificing any chance of fulfilling the same mitzvah as anyone else. One has a chance of fulfilling the full biblical mitzvah of tzitzis and the only cost is financial.
Following the Rambam means dying as few strings as possible. Which is preferred, if one is concerned about losing out by dying a white string. As I thought was clear from context, I wasn’t referring to ignoring other opinions.
Tir’u baTov! -Micha
TM012 — Giorgies E Kepipesiom
Feb 16, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
On Feb 16, 12:16 pm, Ron Aaron <rambam…@gmail.com> wrote:
Where does the Rambam address having 8 lavan altogether?
8 strands, altogether. One techelet and 7 white, or 8 white. hilchot SiSith 1:9.
Again, I don’t see what the problem might be. If the murex dye is not real tekhelet, then they dye is passul, and you have not fulfilled the miswa of tekhelt. But why would it make the entire seesith (or sisith if you insist) pasul.? As I pointed out earlier, even were this strand (actually half-strand) torn off completely the seesith would still be kasher.
GEK
TM013 — Ron Aaron
Feb 17, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
On Feb 16, 8:01 pm, mi…@aishdas.org (Micha Berger) wrote:
No, he gives instruction how to tie if one doesn’t have a blue string to wrap around the others.
Yes… isn’t that obvious ?
have a one-ended string? But the Rambam doesn’t say “make all 8 white”.
No, as you mention “lavan” doesn’t mean white necessarily – but it does mean the strings are the same as the garment. How could the 8th string (if not techelet) be anything *but* white (lavan)?!? Would you have 7 white and a green? I must be missing some very subtle point of yours here.
1:6 states (my translation): “… and one of the eight strands is of techelet, and the other seven, lavan”
1:9 states: “one who makes (the SiSith) lavan without techelet …”
Where is there any room for confusion? You either have all 8 lavan, or 7 lavan and one techelet! As I stated before.
In fact, he says, “If you are making white strings without the techeiles, take on of the 8 strings…” Where is the imperative about the 8th string being white? Third, “lavan” here is a technical term used by the gemara,
What else would the string be but ‘lavan’? Look back at 1:1, where the term “SiSith” and “lavan” are defined! It is impossible to say that if the real ‘techelet’ string is not present, than another string which happens to be dyed the color of techelet but isn’t really valid techelet, could be ‘lavan’ in its place.
Following the Rambam means dying as few strings as possible. Which is preferred, if one is concerned about losing out by dying a white string. As I thought was clear from context, I wasn’t referring to ignoring other opinions.
What is “losing out” in this context? One either performs the miSwah or one does not. The only additional element is whether the techelet is there or not. Invalid techelet *invalidates* the SiSith according to Rambam (2nd chapter). So you “lose out” when you use techelet which is not valid, because in that event your SiSith are invalid, with all that implies.
TM014 — Micha Berger
Feb 17, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
Ron Aaron <rambamist@gmail.com> wrote:
No, as you mention “lavan” doesn’t mean white necessarily – but it does mean the strings are the same as the garment. How could the 8th string (if not techelet) be anything *but* white (lavan)?!? Would you have 7 white and a green? I must be missing some very subtle point of yours here.
7 white and a green is perfectly kosher, not inferior to 8 white. That’s my point. The 8th end of the string is only there to round out the number to 8. For all I know, the Rambam only requires it because it’s impossible to have a string with one end, so you can’t have a tassle with 7 ends.
1:6 states (my translation): “… and one of the eight strands is of techelet, and the other seven, lavan”
1:9 states: “one who makes (the SiSith) lavan without techelet …”
Where is there any room for confusion? You either have all 8 lavan, or 7 lavan and one techelet! As I stated before.
It never says the 8th must be like the lavan strings. Rather, you either have 7 lavan and one techeiles, or you knot 8 strings anyway. That’s al the Rambam says.
Following the Rambam means dying as few strings as possible. Which is preferred, if one is concerned about losing out by dying a white string. As I thought was clear from context, I wasn’t referring to ignoring other opinions.
What is “losing out” in this context? One either performs the miSwah or one does not…
The first could be split further: one could only fulfill the mitzvah bedi’avad (post facto), or even lekhat-chilah (ab initio; IOW, even if you preplanned to do it that way). And even within lechat-khilah, there is a concept of noy (beauty) when it comes to tzitzis which one could miss out on even while totally fulfilling the mitzvah.
According to Tosafos, tzitzis that aren’t white are inferior in one of these two ways — but not entirely valid even post facto.
But even according to them, there is no reason to assume there is a problem with dying the spare strings (Rashi and Tosafos wuld have four such strings, as they rule 4 techeiles, 4 white, per tassle) that are there to round out the number 8.
there or not. Invalid techelet *invalidates* the SiSith according to Rambam (2nd chapter). So you “lose out” when you use techelet which is not valid, because in that event your SiSith are invalid, with all that implies.
The noun which he calls “pesulah” is the dye itself, not the tzitzis. Techeiles einah me’aqeves es halavan — the blue does not hold back [the fulfillment of] the white. So, the tallis may still be worn, and the half of the mitzvah that is wearing the white strings is still fulfilled.
Tir’u baTov! -Micha
TM015 — Giorgies E Kepipesiom
Feb 17, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
On Feb 16, 11:01 pm, mi…@aishdas.org (Micha Berger) wrote:
Ron Aaron <rambam…@gmail.com> wrote:
No, as you mention “lavan” doesn’t mean white necessarily – but it does mean the strings are the same as the garment. How could the 8th string (if not techelet) be anything *but* white (lavan)?!? Would you have 7 white and a green? I must be missing some very subtle point of yours here.
7 white and a green is perfectly kosher, not inferior to 8 white. That’s my point. The 8th end of the string is only there to round out the number to 8. For all I know, the Rambam only requires it because it’s impossible to have a string with one end, so you can’t have a tassle with 7 ends.
1:6 states (my translation): “… and one of the eight strands is of techelet, and the other seven, lavan” 1:9 states: “one who makes (the SiSith) lavan without techelet …”
Where is there any room for confusion? You either have all 8 lavan, or 7 lavan and one techelet! As I stated before.
It never says the 8th must be like the lavan strings. Rather, you either have 7 lavan and one techeiles, or you knot 8 strings anyway. That’s al the Rambam says.
Following the Rambam means dying as few strings as possible. Which is preferred, if one is concerned about losing out by dying a white string. As I thought was clear from context, I wasn’t referring to ignoring other opinions.
What is “losing out” in this context? One either performs the miSwah or one does not…
The first could be split further: one could only fulfill the mitzvah bedi’avad (post facto), or even lekhat-chilah (ab initio; IOW, even if you preplanned to do it that way). And even within lechat-khilah, there is a concept of noy (beauty) when it comes to tzitzis which one could miss out on even while totally fulfilling the mitzvah.
According to Tosafos, tzitzis that aren’t white are inferior in one of these two ways — but not entirely valid even post facto.
But even according to them, there is no reason to assume there is a problem with dying the spare strings (Rashi and Tosafos wuld have four such strings, as they rule 4 techeiles, 4 white, per tassle) that are there to round out the number 8.
there or not. Invalid techelet *invalidates* the SiSith according to Rambam (2nd chapter). So you “lose out” when you use techelet which is not valid, because in that event your SiSith are invalid, with all that implies.
The noun which he calls “pesulah” is the dye itself, not the tzitzis. Techeiles einah me’aqeves es halavan — the blue does not hold back [the fulfillment of] the white. So, the tallis may still be worn, and the half of the mitzvah that is wearing the white strings is still fulfilled.
Once more I repeat the point, alredy made twice, for yet a third time. Even if the 8th strand is missing entirely, having been torn off accidentally (or even on purpose for that matter), the seesith are not passul. Why is a green, or brown, or yellow, passul-tekhelet dyed string worse than no string at all?
GEK
TM016 — Moshe Schorr
Feb 17, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
micha@aishdas.org (Micha Berger) writes:
Ron Aaron <rambamist@gmail.com> wrote:
micha@aishdas.org (Micha Berger) writes:
Following the Rambam also means that one is not sacrificing any chance of fulfilling the same mitzvah as anyone else. One has a chance of fulfilling the full biblical mitzvah of tzitzis and the only cost is financial.
Which of the Rambam’s halachoth are you fulfilling? The one which states that non-kosher techeleth *invalidates* the SiSith? The one which states you must purchase the techeleth from a *mumHeh* (expert) ?
As I wrote earlier in that post:
But that’s for the white strings. But we wear 8 strings even without techeiles. Really: 4 strings with 8 ends hanging out the tassle. 4 of those ends (according to Rashi and Tosafos) or 2 (Raaavad) or 1 (Rambam) are supposed to be blue, and just worn today to round out the full 8.
Even bedi’eved, the replacement has no preferred color.
Umm Micha, you didn’t answer Ron’s objection. And neither of you sited the Rambam’s words. Ron says that the wrong color “*invalidates*”. You say there is “no preferred color”. Could you both please back up your contentions? TIA.
TM017 — Moshe Schorr
Feb 17, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
Giorgies E Kepipesiom <kepipesiom@hotmail.com> writes:
mi…@aishdas.org (Micha Berger) wrote:
Ron Aaron <rambam…@gmail.com> wrote:
mi…@aishdas.org (Micha Berger) wrote:
Following the Rambam also means that one is not sacrificing any chance of fulfilling the same mitzvah as anyone else. One has a chance of fulfilling the full biblical mitzvah of tzitzis and the only cost is financial.
Which of the Rambam’s halachoth are you fulfilling? The one which states that non-kosher techeleth *invalidates* the SiSith? The one which states you must purchase the techeleth from a *mumHeh* (expert) ?
As I wrote earlier in that post:
But that’s for the white strings. But we wear 8 strings even without techeiles. Really: 4 strings with 8 ends hanging out the tassle. 4 of those ends (according to Rashi and Tosafos) or 2 (Raaavad) or 1 (Rambam) are supposed to be blue, and just worn today to round out the full 8.
Even bedi’eved, the replacement has no preferred color.
I am going to violate my own earlier statement that I would not be joining the discussion.
Mutar lach, mutar lach, mutar lach.
And if memory serves, this will be the first time I come to the defense of Micha Berger, whom I am usually on the opposing side of.
So make a “Shehecheyanu”. 🙂
Since the Maimonidean view is that only one half-strand of the eight is dyed tekhelet (i.e., one of the four strands is half white and half tekhelet), using non-kosher tekhelet would not invalidate the seesith, bexause the seesith would be kosher even were that strand entirely missing. See Qisur Shulhan Arukh Chap 9, par 13, about 1/3 way into the paragraph; also Hayyei Adam chapt 11, par 20.
Not necessarily. There can be a case that if it’s missing it’s kosher b’dieved, but if it’s “wrong” it *invalidates*. I would be happy if Ron would post his source.
Nonetheless, because of the safeq, one could not mix wool and linen is this tallith, and so, even were the murex dye genuine tekhelet, the miswa would not be fullfilled in the best possible manner, which would require white strands of linen and blue strand of wool. But would still be prefferable to no blue at all. Having said all this, I still wear white only, until such time as yavo more sedeq veyodieinu.
Me too.
If you are going to use the funny spellings, I would point out the Hebrew name for these strings has a hiriq malei for the first sadi and a hiriq haser for the second. Thus the funny spelling ought be seesith, not sisith.
Nice “catch”.
Regarding the funny capitalistion I will not comment save to point out that there is no need to capitalise this word at all.
I don’t think it’s capitalization. I think Ron uses a transliteration scheme which has “S” for “tzadi”. And after giving us “Purime”, you’re in no position to talk about “funny spellings”.
Gershon Eliyahu no longer a disciple of Master Israel Tekhelet
Were you ever?
TM018 — Moshe Schorr
Feb 17, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
micha@aishdas.org (Micha Berger) writes:
Ron Aaron <rambamist@gmail.com> wrote:
It is an interesting assertion that the eight is a “replacement”. Either you have seven “lavan” and one “techelet”, or eight “lavan”. What is your support for saying the Rambam says otherwise? I do not see that in the M”T anywhere.
Where does the Rambam address having 8 lavan altogether?
Chapter 1 Par 9. (Courtesy of Machon mamre).
And why am I constrained to the Rambam?
From the previous post, which was unfortunately snipped, I at least, got the impression that you were supporting yourself on the Rambam which says “the replacement can be any color” (or WTTE). I didn’t see any support for that in the Rambam. What’s your source.
TM019 — Moshe Schorr
Feb 17, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
Giorgies E Kepipesiom <kepipesiom@hotmail.com> writes:
On Feb 16, 12:16 pm, Ron Aaron <rambam…@gmail.com> wrote:
Where does the Rambam address having 8 lavan altogether?
8 strands, altogether. One techelet and 7 white, or 8 white. hilchot SiSith 1:9.
Again, I don’t see what the problem might be. If the murex dye is not real tekhelet, then they dye is passul, and you have not fulfilled the miswa of tekhelt. But why would it make the entire seesith (or sisith if you insist) pasul.? As I pointed out earlier, even were this strand (actually half-strand) torn off completely the seesith would still be kasher.
There are situations where “missing” is OK but “wrong” is not. For example, certain organs in an animal. If it is missing, the animal is still kosher, but if it is perforated the animal is treif.
TM020 — Micha Berger
Feb 17, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
moshes@mm.huji.ac.il wrote:
Where does the Rambam address having 8 lavan altogether?
Chapter 1 Par 9. (Courtesy of Machon mamre).
He doesn’t say you need to use 8 lavan, he says “Whoever is making tzitzis of lvan without techeiles, takes one of the 8 strings, and winds it on the others…”
And why am I constrained to the Rambam?
From the previous post, which was unfortunately snipped, I at least, got the impression that you were supporting yourself on the Rambam which says “the replacement can be any color” (or WTTE). I didn’t see any support for that in the Rambam. What’s your source.
My LOR, actually. My point was that R SR Hirsch’s symbology is based on assuming the Rambam’s 7 white, 1 blue, which is what motivated me. Now, given that I’m coloring as few strings as possible (by following the Rambam), there is no opinion by which I am coloring a string that is supposed to remain white.
My LOR’s response was to the tune of: I am not convinced the likelihood is high enough to jutify wasting the money. However, given your perception of the historical point, this is how you should do it.
Tir’u baTov! -Micha
TM021 — Micha Berger
Feb 17, 2009 · Re: tekhelet · Archive message lookup
moshes@mm.huji.ac.il wrote:
Umm Micha, you didn’t answer Ron’s objection. And neither of you sited the Rambam’s words. Ron says that the wrong color “*invalidates*”. You say there is “no preferred color”. Could you both please back up your contentions? TIA.
There is a preferred color– for techeiles. And Hilkhos Tzitzis 2:4-7 are the law of how to make sure you got techeiles that is not only the real thing, but dyed for the sake of the mitzvah. I am arguing that when he says another dye is pasul (e.g. at the end of 2:4) he is speaking of pasul for techeiles, not that the tzitzis is pasul even WRT lavan. Because the wording is just that — that the dye is pesulah.
Tir’u baTov! -Micha
Archive Notes and Original Signatures
The information below is preserved for verification and attribution. Google Groups links search by Message-ID; they have not been verified as direct links to individual posts. The main transcript above retains quoted text in full, including repeated passages.
TM001 — mm
Original From: mm <NOPSAMmm2005@bigfoot.com>
Original date: Feb 16, 2009 | Original Date header: Mon, 16 Feb 2009 01:20:38 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <hqdhp41vdq33gg1ofo1gonqidv39jgubit@4ax.com>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109178; byte range [445892637, 445894957).
TM002 — Adelle
Original From: “Adelle” <adstavisatgmail.com@invalid.invalid>
Original date: Feb 16, 2009 | Original Date header: Mon, 16 Feb 2009 01:33:22 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <gnaf4m$jn5$1@news.motzarella.org>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109181; byte range [445901273, 445904426).
TM003 — Micha Berger
Original From: micha@aishdas.org (Micha Berger)
Original date: Feb 16, 2009 | Original Date header: Mon, 16 Feb 2009 01:48:31 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <gnagjk$890$1@harrier.steinthal.us>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109186; byte range [445915186, 445919848).
Original email signature:
Micha Berger Strength does not come from winning. Your micha@aishdas.org struggles develop your strength When you go http://www.aishdas.org through hardship and decide not to surrender, Fax: (270) 514-1507 that is strength. – Arnold Schwarzenegger
TM004 — Ron Aaron
Original From: Ron Aaron <rambamist@gmail.com>
Original date: Feb 16, 2009 | Original Date header: Mon, 16 Feb 2009 11:43:38 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <f4ed9aac-fe23-4759-aabe-b0f340eb39d3@f3g2000yqf.googlegroups.com>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109133; byte range [445738373, 445740916).
TM005 — Micha Berger
Original From: micha@aishdas.org (Micha Berger)
Original date: Feb 16, 2009 | Original Date header: Mon, 16 Feb 2009 12:56:30 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <gnbno2$td0$1@harrier.steinthal.us>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109135; byte range [445744355, 445747147).
Original email signature:
Micha Berger It is our choices…that show what we truly are, micha@aishdas.org far more than our abilities. http://www.aishdas.org – J. K. Rowling Fax: (270) 514-1507
TM006 — Giorgies E Kepipesiom
Original From: Giorgies E Kepipesiom <kepipesiom@hotmail.com>
Original date: Feb 16, 2009 | Original Date header: Mon, 16 Feb 2009 13:25:14 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <ea36fd17-43bb-4f49-ae10-ef10ed2d0f0c@33g2000yqm.googlegroups.com>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109138; byte range [445755052, 445759542).
TM007 — mirjam
Original From: mirjam@actcom.co.il
Original date: Feb 16, 2009 | Original Date header: Mon, 16 Feb 2009 14:15:15 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <8da40d96-2869-4e41-bf42-72f78f6bfd9a@j1g2000yqi.googlegroups.com>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 108956; byte range [445125330, 445127210).
TM008 — Ron Aaron
Original From: Ron Aaron <rambamist@gmail.com>
Original date: Feb 16, 2009 | Original Date header: Mon, 16 Feb 2009 15:21:51 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <d4d557af-c049-493b-89d0-ec7a721af156@j8g2000yql.googlegroups.com>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 108969; byte range [445166611, 445169192).
TM009 — Micha Berger
Original From: micha@aishdas.org (Micha Berger)
Original date: Feb 16, 2009 | Original Date header: Mon, 16 Feb 2009 16:28:18 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <gnc46n$4lo$1@harrier.steinthal.us>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 108974; byte range [445181341, 445183636).
Original email signature:
Micha Berger It is our choices…that show what we truly are, micha@aishdas.org far more than our abilities. http://www.aishdas.org – J. K. Rowling Fax: (270) 514-1507
TM010 — Ron Aaron
Original From: Ron Aaron <rambamist@gmail.com>
Original date: Feb 16, 2009 | Original Date header: Mon, 16 Feb 2009 17:16:16 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <2f6efd32-6bb9-4286-98a8-6f36c16a7f3e@j35g2000yqh.googlegroups.com>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 108982; byte range [445204137, 445206613).
TM011 — Micha Berger
Original From: micha@aishdas.org (Micha Berger)
Original date: Feb 16, 2009 | Original Date header: Mon, 16 Feb 2009 18:01:01 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <gnc9j1$7c9$1@harrier.steinthal.us>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 108984; byte range [445209334, 445212872).
Original email signature:
Micha Berger It is our choices…that show what we truly are, micha@aishdas.org far more than our abilities. http://www.aishdas.org – J. K. Rowling Fax: (270) 514-1507
TM012 — Giorgies E Kepipesiom
Original From: Giorgies E Kepipesiom <kepipesiom@hotmail.com>
Original date: Feb 16, 2009 | Original Date header: Mon, 16 Feb 2009 22:19:52 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <d16ca8eb-b880-4022-b0ef-7d89f725ce0c@t11g2000yqg.googlegroups.com>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109063; byte range [445492107, 445494919).
TM013 — Ron Aaron
Original From: Ron Aaron <rambamist@gmail.com>
Original date: Feb 17, 2009 | Original Date header: Tue, 17 Feb 2009 03:24:36 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <df9e8c96-e5e3-4e57-bf7d-e4aaa739a7c9@x38g2000yqj.googlegroups.com>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109089; byte range [445589008, 445593121).
TM014 — Micha Berger
Original From: micha@aishdas.org (Micha Berger)
Original date: Feb 17, 2009 | Original Date header: Tue, 17 Feb 2009 04:01:02 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <gndco8$pcd$1@harrier.steinthal.us>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109091; byte range [445597017, 445601931).
Original email signature:
Micha Berger It is our choices…that show what we truly are, micha@aishdas.org far more than our abilities. http://www.aishdas.org – J. K. Rowling Fax: (270) 514-1507
TM015 — Giorgies E Kepipesiom
Original From: Giorgies E Kepipesiom <kepipesiom@hotmail.com>
Original date: Feb 17, 2009 | Original Date header: Tue, 17 Feb 2009 04:37:24 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <ffccc2a5-ebb1-4aba-acc2-adc935ef9d1f@w34g2000yqm.googlegroups.com>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109093; byte range [445604155, 445609698).
TM016 — Moshe Schorr
Original From: moshes@mm.huji.ac.il
Original date: Feb 17, 2009 | Original Date header: Tue, 17 Feb 2009 06:58:14 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <2009Feb17.085338@mm.huji.ac.il>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109099; byte range [445622384, 445625523).
Original email signature:
Moshe Schorr
It is a tremendous Mitzvah to always be happy! – Reb Nachman of Breslov The home and family are the center of Judaism, *not* the synagogue. May Eliezer Mordichai b. Chaya Sheina Rochel have a refuah shlaimah btoch sha’ar cholei Yisroel. Disclaimer: Nothing here necessarily reflects the opinion of Hebrew University
TM017 — Moshe Schorr
Original From: moshes@mm.huji.ac.il
Original date: Feb 17, 2009 | Original Date header: Tue, 17 Feb 2009 07:20:16 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <2009Feb17.091454@mm.huji.ac.il>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109100; byte range [445625523, 445630458).
Original email signature:
Moshe Schorr
It is a tremendous Mitzvah to always be happy! – Reb Nachman of Breslov The home and family are the center of Judaism, *not* the synagogue. May Eliezer Mordichai b. Chaya Sheina Rochel have a refuah shlaimah btoch sha’ar cholei Yisroel. Disclaimer: Nothing here necessarily reflects the opinion of Hebrew University
TM018 — Moshe Schorr
Original From: moshes@mm.huji.ac.il
Original date: Feb 17, 2009 | Original Date header: Tue, 17 Feb 2009 07:53:19 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <2009Feb17.094838@mm.huji.ac.il>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109003; byte range [445281971, 445284734).
Original email signature:
Moshe Schorr
It is a tremendous Mitzvah to always be happy! – Reb Nachman of Breslov The home and family are the center of Judaism, *not* the synagogue. May Eliezer Mordichai b. Chaya Sheina Rochel have a refuah shlaimah btoch sha’ar cholei Yisroel. Disclaimer: Nothing here necessarily reflects the opinion of Hebrew University
TM019 — Moshe Schorr
Original From: moshes@mm.huji.ac.il
Original date: Feb 17, 2009 | Original Date header: Tue, 17 Feb 2009 08:11:48 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <2009Feb17.100700@mm.huji.ac.il>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109004; byte range [445284734, 445287502).
Original email signature:
Moshe Schorr
It is a tremendous Mitzvah to always be happy! – Reb Nachman of Breslov The home and family are the center of Judaism, *not* the synagogue. May Eliezer Mordichai b. Chaya Sheina Rochel have a refuah shlaimah btoch sha’ar cholei Yisroel. Disclaimer: Nothing here necessarily reflects the opinion of Hebrew University
TM020 — Micha Berger
Original From: micha@aishdas.org (Micha Berger)
Original date: Feb 17, 2009 | Original Date header: Tue, 17 Feb 2009 11:38:39 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <gne7ig$5m1$2@harrier.steinthal.us>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109015; byte range [445320616, 445323874).
Original email signature:
Micha Berger I long to accomplish a great and noble task, micha@aishdas.org but it is my chief duty to accomplish small http://www.aishdas.org tasks as if they were great and noble. Fax: (270) 514-1507 – Helen Keller
TM021 — Micha Berger
Original From: micha@aishdas.org (Micha Berger)
Original date: Feb 17, 2009 | Original Date header: Tue, 17 Feb 2009 11:44:46 +0000 (UTC)
Message-ID: <gne7v3$5m1$3@harrier.steinthal.us>
Archive source: soc.culture.jewish.moderated.mbox; numeric message 109016; byte range [445323874, 445326600).
Original email signature:
Micha Berger I long to accomplish a great and noble task, micha@aishdas.org but it is my chief duty to accomplish small http://www.aishdas.org tasks as if they were great and noble. Fax: (270) 514-1507 – Helen Keller